Snow White and the Seven Dwarves, Adapted by Lisa Ann Marsoli. Published 1993.
This book was written after the Walt Disney version of Snow White. It starts with the evil stepmother queen wanting to be the most beautiful in the land, but worries that her step daughter will overtake that. Snow White works as a servant a meets a handsome prince. The queen though is told by her mirror that Snow White is more beautiful and orders her huntsman to kill her. The huntsman takes her to the woods but cannot do it and sends Snow White away and lies to the queen. Snow white finds refuge in a little cottage who belongs to the seven dwarfs. They come home and once they find out who she is they welcome her. Meanwhile the queen finds out the Snow White is still alive, so she turn herself into a hag to disguise herself from Snow White. The dwarfs go off to work and Snow White is visited by the queen and given a poison apple which she takes a bite and goes into a deep sleep. The dwarfs come to rescue her and the queen dies but Snow White doesn't wake up. The dwarfs put her in a glass coffin and the prince finds her and kisses her and she wakes. They go off happily to the castle and are married.
I chose this book because Snow White was my favorite princess as a child. I thought it would be interesting to look at it in a new light. I noticed that the characters were all white. So the people in power are white, the queen, prince and Snow White if you want to count her. Snow White having fair white skin is described as being the fairest in the land. So we can attribute a mixed message that beauty equals white skin. The queen has the consequence of her vanity and trying to kill Snow White, she ends up dead from falling off the cliff. Also she has to turn herself ugly to try to kill Snow White so it is kind of hypocritical. You also get the message of beauty is not alway happiness on the queen's part. But Snow White does get the happy ending and she is the most beautiful, but she is also kind. The dwarfs have silly names that fit their character, which can be attributed to short people being silly. Which could be offensive. They are also the ones who go out and work and Snow White stays home and cooks and cleans, some gender roles there.
All in all, the book gives off a good message of don't be obsessed with looks, and that kindness pays off. I don't see anything overtly wrong with this book and I would recommend it and versions like it. Other cultures are not really represented which is unfortunate, but their aren't too many characters so it is kind of hard. This is kind of considered a classic, a very dumbed down version of it but still. You can see some of that old time stereotypes shining through still.
I think it is always interesting to read an old favorite and see how it compares with some new knowledge. This feels a little rushed and incomplete, but you have a nice start. Some words are a bit tumbled together in an informal way. Remember that this college level writing despite being a "blog." I would never use Disney versions of anything in a classroom. If this is a favorite story, I would suggest finding a better version with more interesting illustrations and a more detailed story. Here is an example: http://www.amazon.com/Snow-White-Seven-Dwarfs-Sunburst-Book/dp/0374468680/ref=cm_cr_pr_product_top
ReplyDeleteVery interesting analysis! I never thought of the gender roles of her staying in cooking and cleaning because I just thought of it has she has to because she is hiding from the queen. Awesome! I also never thought of the dwarfs being "little people" and how those people could really take offense to that. Great job! You opened my eyes a bit wider. :)
ReplyDeleteHi Briana, It’s so odd seeing the classic type fairy tale stories in a different perspective. I’ve noticed the gender roles in quite a few of them. I definitely would not have related ‘fairest’ to her skin when reading the book before this class. As for the dwarfs, I don’t think the names are attributed to short people in any way. I do like the message about “don't be obsessed with looks, and that kindness pays off”. That is the same message I get from it. I also think that is something we really need to teach our children as so much in society focuses in on what 'beauty' is supposed to look like.
ReplyDelete